Tattoos have been frowned upon for centuries. In western civilization, Tattoo is a term often associated with self-disrespect, self-destruction, self-mutilation, drug addiction and crime. Ever since we met the omniscient and all-powerful biblical God, people have criminalized tattooing and declared it a taboo. Although a taboo is a non-political prohibition, the tattooed still face challenges on many levels of social interaction. The act of permanently marking the skin with ink and with the use of needles is considered not only a disrespect to yourself and your body but also as a disrespect to God, who meticulously designed and created you. The belief in God is a deep root of our society, and even though now this society is religiously diverse, certain religious morals and values have become a significant part of our culture. Therefore, the disapproval of tattoos is now, also, a part of culture. Different cultures develop different customs and moral codes; what is a taboo to one group of people may not be to the other. For instance, tattooing was forbidden to Jews by God in the Torah; Brazil, as a Catholic nation, frowns upon it; on the other hand, it is an important ritual of maturity for the Omaha of North America. As a government, the framework of society, becomes more and more secular and major cities become more and more diverse, the way society deals with religion changes resulting in religion becoming less and less noticeable in the culture. In places where this has happened, such as New York, the way the community perceives tattoos is absolutely different from the way communities significantly influenced by religion perceive it. The belief in God is the main reason why tattoos are frowned upon in certain communities, and as society becomes religiously unbiased, tattoos consequently become more accepted.
In Brazil, a major fear of being tattooed is that it might prevent you from ever getting a job. In fact, if you have tattoos it is instantly assumed that you have never attended college and have no prospect of ever pursuing a career. Ironically, that originates from the belief that you don’t care about what others think, aside from the fact that you have no self-respect and are (or were) probably a druggy. Devout Christians (The predominant part of the population) criminalize tattoos for the following reason: it is disrespect to one’s body, which is a gift from God. Disrespect, however, is rarely discussed in this context; they believe someone who gets a tattoo essentially tells God they don’t appreciate or cherish what He has given them- a human body and life. In other words, getting tattooed is like tagging the school’s desk, it shows an utter lack of respect for something one is given by an authority and takes full use of. By doing that, these Catholics impose their religious values on others, as if following the Christian values was the only honorable way of living. Even non-religious Brazilians have difficulty not making assumptions about tattoos because of the overwhelming influence of the majority; even atheists wouldn’t get a tattoo and believe it is a bad idea for anyone else to get a tattoo because it would lead to societal rejection. Consequently, if you have no desire to be accepted by society there is just no hope for you. The irony is that since the belief is not retained in the religious community, tattoos become frowned upon by society as a whole. In addition to that, these people take for granted the fact that it is impossible to draw a line between how much of our body it is acceptable change under the judgment of God- while tattoos are not acceptable, hair dying, hair plugs, body waxing, artificial tanning, makeup, henna tattoos, organ transplant and medicine in general, even permanent makeup (which is essentially tattooing) is acceptable, as soon as it is not body art.
To the Jews, who believe in the same God as Christians, tattoos are also culturally forbidden. In the Jewish culture, tattooing is “the custom of idolaters to inscribe themselves [by tattooing] to an idol, to indicate that they were bondslaves to it and devoted to its service (Encyclopaedia Judaica, Yad, Avodah Zarah 12:11).” Here, tattoo is the mark of slavery and submission to a higher being. Since the word tattoo is not explicitly mentioned, the texts of the Torah changed throughout time into meaning that an individual is only culpable of the transgression if he or she tattoos with indelible ink. Later, according to the interpretation of the Talmud, one is only guilty if he or she tattoos the name of an idol. To the Jewish community today, tattoos in general are just distasteful, but to tattoo the name of an idol is still a taboo. The belief, which originated from regular men who tattooed the things they liked or had much respect for in life, is that it is the act of tattooing and the tattoo itself that generates the devotion. Eternal devotion to an idol generates fear for Jews, because it leads to slavery and eternal powerlessness (These regular men, amusingly, were sailors that tattooed things like naked women and anchors). Jews, as well as Christians, believe the body is a wonderful gift from God. To tattoo the skin is a disrespect to God, and as punishment the individual loses free will and is until death bound to servitude to an idol (other than God).
On the other hand, in the Omaha tribe of North America, tattooing is part of an essential ritual in a young woman’s life. Each stage of maturity is represented in the designs tattooed in the girl’s body; “The designs tattooed on the girl were all cosmic symbols (Fletcher, The Mark of Honor).” The tattooing would start when the sun is in its highest point in the arch and her body is exactly between the sun and the center of the earth; at that point the experiences a “shift in perspective” or a vision. The symbols represent day and night while she is perfectly centered between earth and sky. When the girl’s father becomes the “Order of chief,” a position that holds great power and reputation, his achievements would be tattooed on his daughter’s forehead and throat, called “the mark of honor.” She makes the greatest effort to not cry or express pain; now as woman she will be called “woman chief.” The members of the Omaha tribe do not know the single all-powerful God of the Christian and Jewish religions; their religion is based on the relationship between people and nature. Their God can be interpreted as Nature, but in that case their relationship with God is exceptionally different, it is based on harmony and balance, rather than worshipping and homage. While the Catholics have symbols such as the Cross and triptych paintings, the Omaha have nature theme tattoos.
In comparison to the Jewish culture, the medieval Christian belief of symbolic and intellectual proximity is similar to the servitude caused by tattoos in the eyes of the Jews, while the tattooing ritual of the Omaha tribe can be clearly associated with Catholic medieval triptych paintings. This type of painting consisting of three associated paintings enables the patron to be portrayed in close proximity to a divine symbol such as the Virgin and Child, indicating vivid devotion, and also indicating high rank in society (since only a few could afford it). “The imagery on a triptych’s wings is subservient to that on the central pane – and the donor portraits typically appear on the wings (Hand).” When the wings were folded together the donor would be face-to-face with the Virgin Mary. Late Medieval philosophy did not sharply distinguish the concepts of literal sight from insight, or between actual and inner vision, so the actual proximity meant spiritual proximity. While one is devoted to the Virgin Mary and wants to be portrayed in close proximity to Her, one becomes a servant of the idol he or she permanently marks on his or her skin. In the Omaha tribe, the tattooing ritual is performed at a specific time of the day and specific time in the development of the girl’s body and maturity. Undergoing the painful process while mediating the center of the earth and the Sun, symbolizes balance between body and nature, and being in harmony with their God. Similar to the Christian triptych, this process also has the aspect of societal rank, since the father’s achievements are tattooed on specific parts of the daughter’s body, defining her status. In spite of the conceptual similarities of the rituals, Europeans, particularly during and after the era of colonization, viewed these indigenous tribes as savage, and these are the roots for the belief we’ve had in recent history towards the tattooed.
In New York, America’s largest city, I have noticed that religion is rather secondary in social relationships and the community is exceptionally receptive to tattoos. Ever since its independence, The United States has been a protestant nation; in fact, Protestantism was one of the motivations for independence. Even though the constitution underwent many changes, it is still today significantly close to the Ten Commandments. Abraham holding the two tablets and other biblical references are often depicted on the walls of courthouses, all our leaders reference the name of God, and in fact over 80% of the adult American population believes God took part in the creation of humans (76% of the population consider themselves Christian). However, American society, in large cities at least, is becoming more and more open-minded towards tattoos. Due to the diversity and to a wide variety of not only religions but also cultures and sub-cultures and beliefs in general, New Yorkers tend to see religion as something as personal as one’s favorite ice-cream flavor. This philosophy is now very much alive in the constitution; freedom of religion and even abortion laws follow this pattern.
When it comes to tattoos, New Yorkers have almost an opposite reaction to the reaction of the believers of the all-powerful God- they see them as hip. In many large and diverse cities across the world, tattoos are also becoming more and more respected as art and also as an attitude. The tattooed are often seen as strong- not only strong for overcoming the physical pain but also for overcoming the fear of permanence and regret, and possibly change. However, subcultures that idolize the tattooed may suddenly make not getting a tattoo a taboo. As a lover of tattoos living in New York, I’ve experienced a wide variety of reactions to my tattoos. I was fired from a waiting job when I got my second tattoo and I was also hired at a clothing store for having tattoos; People ask me if they are real, where I got them, if it hurts, if I can hook them up with my tattoo artist, why I have tattoos and what do they mean. For someone to mark something permanently on their body, the design must be bursting with meaning, something that defines them, or has a significant history. In this progressive group of people that respect tattoos, meaning is essential. Otherwise, the tattoo is just a spur of the moment and you will definitely regret it in a couple of years. In a polar way, judgment still exists and a middle ground won’t appear overnight.
Different cultures have significantly different perspectives over the same subject. Jews and Christians believe in the same God, and both reject tattooing. For the Jews, the fear and prohibition of tattoos comes from the imaginary danger of eternal submission, and in Brazil tattoos are seen as a disrespect to one’s body and to God. In contrast, the Omaha see tattoos as a “mark of honor” and of harmony of the body and the universe. The main difference between all these religions is that they have different views of God. Christians and Jews see the human body as God’s holy creation while the Omaha see the body in relationship with the universe, earth and sky. Acknowledging that people have different beliefs is key to being open-minded towards not only tattoos but to nearly everything. That is quintessence of New York City and also the reason why NYC is a distinguished American city. Accepting differences can solve many social, political and personal issues, and most importantly it might help one achieve a better understanding about oneself, and one’s own personal beliefs as well. Gradually, tattoos are being accepted by the general public as art, as interesting, and respected as a personal choice. I believe this is happening because of a gradual change on the way the general public perceives religion. Religion is gradually losing presence in politics, even though gay marriage is still illegal and God is often mentioned by political leaders and in the constitution. Nevertheless, the way tattoos are perceived is a problematic detail on the in the structure of society, that is slowly being resolved as we evolve towards secularism.
Works Cited
Encyclopaedia Judaica. "Tattoo." Eds. Michael Berenbaum and Fred Skolnik. Vol. 19. 2nd ed. Detroit: Macmillan Reference USA, 2007.
Fletcher, Alice Cunningham. The Omaha Tribe. Nebraska: University of Nebraska, 1992.
Hand, John Oliver. Portraits: Unfolding the Netherlandish Diptych. United States: Yale University Press, 2006.